Exploring Marvel’s missed casting choices and Alan Ritchson’s untapped potential in the realm of the MCU.

SUMMARY

The 2022 MCU film Thor: Love & Thunder introduced Brett Goldstein as Hercules, who made a brief appearance in the mid-credit scene of the movie.
However, many have argued that Alan Ritchson could have been a much better choice for the role of the demigod.

Known for starring in the crime thriller Reacher, Alan Ritchson has transited a remarkable journey since his early days, marked by his debut as Aquaman in the superhero series Smallville. His portrayal of DC’s Hawk in Max’s Titans further solidified his presence in the comic book realm.

Alan Ritchson in Reacher
Along with his DC roles, the actor also attempted to conquer the Marvel Cinematic Universe, by auditioning for the role of Thor. While the part ultimately went to Chris Hemsworth, Ritchson’s potential for embodying legendary figures like Hercules remains evident, presenting a missed opportunity for Marvel.

The 2022 MCU film Thor: Love & Thunder introduced Brett Goldstein as Hercules, who made a brief appearance in the mid-credit scene of the movie. But the Ted Lasso star’s future in the superhero universe following the brief cameo remains uncertain.

Brett Goldstein as Hercules in Thor: Love & Thunder
However, many have argued that Alan Ritchson could have been a much better choice for the role of the demigod. The actor not only has a striking appearance but also has an on-screen presence that commands attention, making him a natural fit to portray larger-than-life personas like Hercules.

His stature with chiseled muscles is perfect to embody the physicality and strength synonymous with the character. Love & Thunder shows Zeus sending Hercules to confront Thor, and Ritchson has the physicality and demeanor that could make him a formidable opponent to the God of Thunder.

A still from Reacher
His versatility as an actor and significant fan support make him the ideal candidate. However, despite Ritchson’s suitability for the role, Marvel decided to cast Goldstein instead. The decision has also left many fans disappointed, who have argued that the Fast X actor would have been a better fit for the role of Hercules.

Alan Ritchson Auditioned For the Role of Thor in the MCU

In a recent interview with Men’s Health, Alan Ritchson revealed that he auditioned for the role of the Marvel superhero Thor. He shared that he was tired of being the “loud funny guy” and decided to audition for the role of Thor for the 2011 Marvel film.

Chris Hemsworth as Thor in a still from Thor: Love and Thunder
However, the actor did not take it seriously and believed that he would get the role based on his looks. “I didn’t take it seriously,” he said before adding, “I was like, ‘They’ll throw me the part if I look like the guy; nobody really cares about acting.’”

He was later told that although he had a significant opportunity, he had not showcased “the craft” to make a noteworthy impact during auditions. Ritchson would go on to lose the opportunity to star in the MCU to the Australian actor Chris Hemsworth, who has since portrayed the character.

Alan Ritchson in The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare
Despite losing such a significant opportunity, the 41-year-old actor has continued to make his mark in the industry, relying not only on his looks but also on the strength of his performances and his ability to fully embody his characters. Ritchson is set to star in the upcoming spy action comedy film, The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare, which is set to release on April 19, 2024.